A "Fearsome Foursome" of high school girls with wicked gossip and backstabbing on their minds makes a bet that whomever brings down one of their rivals will get to have the hot new single guy. Sally arranges to speak to all of her exes to discover why her current guy, Stan, might be thinking of breaking up with her, and the first on the list is the sexual stamina king, Jake. Emma and Brian discover that their last bout of sex-with-sock-puppets accidentally went out over the internet via her Web site.