Ian and Lucy are trapped at his cabin without Caleb's ""water."" Offering to stay with him through his crisis, Lucy kisses him and they soon make love. Rafe demands the yacht captain tell him what he knows about Joshua, Caleb and Malcolm's death. The captain then leads Rafe to a graveyard and Rafe begins digging. Joshua threatens to kill Alison for learning too much. When he intends to have his way with her first, Elizabeth jumps up and bites him. When Tess goes home from the hospital, she tells Jack not to worry about Caleb. As a butterfly, Caleb lures Tess to the woods, then surprises her with a horse-drawn carriage.