A distraught Frank comes to the lighthouse seeking help from Kevin. Meanwhile, Ricky reassures Karen as she shakily recounts her latest encounter with her volatile boyfriend. Suggesting to Rafe that he's been unfairly treated by his heavenly masters, James offers the angel a lifetime with his lady love if he chooses to switch sides. Karen explains to a startled Ricky how she became a pill-popping stripper after being sexually molested as a child. Frank relates for Kevin how he suddenly saw the woman he loves as a cheap slut just as he popped the question. While an eavesdropping Livvie perks up her ears, Kevin questions his puzzled patient about the candle he lit to set the mood for his proposal. James shows Rafe the enchanting future he could have with Alison once he signs on with a new ""boss"". An unwitting Ricky brings Karen the candle from the Scanlon house to give her comfort. Rafe informs a sneering James that he cannot accept his offer.